If you ask me, Michael Bay's work on The Island to me was the worst. Its not really his genre to do a science fiction film at all. Furthermore, the plot was not even original. What is good is probably the fast pacing of the film. What is bad was the outcome of it... the clones are release into the unknown world... so what are they going to do when the host and the clone meets?
I felt dissapointed because I'm a big fan of Michael Bay. Armageddon and Bad Boys were good. Remember The Rock? That was good! But Pearl Harbor is only good on one scene, the rest was a big yawn. The Island to me rated the worst out of some of his films he has made today... and not only that the movie and my opinion said so it is bad... the box office takings in North America too.